Nuclear weapons don't kill people. People kill people.

(idea) by robwicks Mon Jul 14 2003 at 20:34:56
This argument is a favorite non sequitur of gun control advocates. It really only holds if one regards all weapons as morally equal. It is a bit of a stretch to regard nuclear weapons as the moral equivalent of guns.

A gun is a weapon which can be used (and is almost always used) by one individual against another individual. A nuclear weapon is useless against individuals and is only used against large groups of people for indiscriminate killing. A nation, even one with an aggressive army is never comprised of only aggressors. Using a gun against an invading army is a case of people using a weapon against someone who is actively attempting to kill them. Nuking a city kills innocent people along with guilty, hence its immorality.

A nuclear weapon is one which is impossible to use against only military targets, which is why I don't support them being used. I would never support the legalization of a weapon for the government which is not also legal for the individual. The real question is why would anyone who considers themselves moral, would think that is fine to use a nuclear weapon under any circumstance, be that use by a government or an individual. Why is government exempt from morality simply because it is a group of people acting?

A gun can be used in a just cause, by an individual, to protect the innocent against an aggressor without violating the rights of anyone. A nuclear weapon cannot be used in such a limited manner.

Droidkevin5 reminded me of the difference between strategic nuclear weapons, which are the only kind ever actually used in a war, and tactical nuclear weapons, low yield devices used specifically against military targets with a small blast radius and low/no impact on civilian areas. Those might be usable in a moral manner. But what we normally know as the bomb is a weapon which can only be used in a murderous manner in a war between nations.

No more writeups are being accepted for this node. Enough already. If you feel you have something to add to this node, post it on your Scratch Pad and contact an editor.